If you’re even a little bit into fragrances, you’ve probably heard about Creed’s Green Irish Tweed—one of the most legendary “gentlemanly” scents out there. But let’s be real: not everyone wants to spend $400–$500 on a bottle, no matter how iconic it is. That’s where the world of inspired, budget-friendly alternatives comes in. And right now, one of the hottest contenders is Al Haramain Amber Oud Carbon Edition. With a name that might sound mysterious but a scent that’s immediately familiar, this fragrance is winning over fans who want that fresh, refined Green Irish Tweed vibe—without the luxury price tag.
In this detailed review, I’ll break down how Amber Oud Carbon Edition smells, how it wears, how it stacks up against the classics (yes, including Cool Water and Aspen!), and why it’s one of the best affordable summer and all-season scents on the market today.
First Impressions: Presentation & Price
Let’s start with the basics: presentation. The bottle fits right into the Amber Oud family, with the same squared-off shape and a sturdy cap, but here you get sleek silver accents instead of gold or black. It feels solid in the hand and looks sharp on the shelf—definitely a touch more “grown up” than most department store options. The sprayer distributes a fine, even mist, so you can easily control how much you apply.
And the price? This is where things get exciting. At around $77 for 100ml (sometimes less if you shop sales), it’s about one-sixth the cost of a Creed bottle—sometimes even cheaper if you find a good deal. For a high-quality “inspired by” fragrance with great performance, that’s a win.
The Scent: A Familiar, Fresh, and Classy Vibe
Now for the important part: the juice inside. Don’t let the name “Amber Oud” fool you—there’s actually no amber or oud in this scent at all! Instead, it borrows the branding from Al Haramain’s other popular releases. This one is all about a fresh, green, slightly aquatic, and very refined profile, clearly taking its inspiration from Green Irish Tweed.
Opening:
The first spray is bright and uplifting. You get an immediate wave of citrus—bergamot and a hint of lemon—with an aromatic, almost soapy-clean undertone from the lavender and sage. There’s also a fresh “watery” quality, thanks to oceanic notes, that keeps it modern and wearable even in the heat.
Heart:
As it settles, you start to pick up a gentle floral layer, mostly geranium, which keeps things clean and crisp. There’s a subtle grassiness and a powdery, almost iris-like feel (even though iris isn’t officially listed). The sage continues to add a touch of herbal green.
Dry Down:
The base is soft woods, just enough to keep it from being too light or fleeting. It’s not a sweet or heavy scent—no vanilla, amber, or oud lurking in the background. The woods here are clean and understated, perfectly supporting that fresh, “well-groomed” aura.
Is It Really Like Creed Green Irish Tweed?
Let’s address the elephant in the room: How close is Amber Oud Carbon Edition to Green Irish Tweed?
Short answer: it’s very close—definitely one of the best affordable alternatives out there. The main difference is that Green Irish Tweed features more prominent lemon verbena, violet leaf, and iris, which create its signature floral-citrus-green blend. Amber Oud Carbon Edition takes a slightly more aromatic, aquatic, and herbal route with its lavender, bergamot, sage, and oceanic notes.
If you’ve worn Davidoff Cool Water (another “inspired by” GIT classic), you’ll notice some similarities. But Amber Oud Carbon Edition feels more modern and lively, especially in the opening, and isn’t as watered-down as some recent batches of Cool Water. Coty Aspen is also in the same family, but it’s woodier and doesn’t have the same sparkling, citrus-green freshness.
If you want the GIT vibe for a fraction of the price—and stronger, longer-lasting performance than Cool Water—this is your best bet.
Performance: Longevity, Projection, & Versatility
How does Amber Oud Carbon Edition perform in the real world? Here’s what I found after testing it in different situations:
Longevity:
Solid. I get 7–8 hours on my skin, sometimes a little less on a hot day, a little more when the weather is cool or I spray on clothes. For a fresh scent, that’s excellent—especially at this price point.
Projection:
The first 45 minutes to an hour, it projects nicely within an arm’s length. You’ll get noticed in an elevator, at work, or during casual hangouts. After about four hours, it settles to a softer scent bubble (maybe elbow’s length), and by hour seven or eight, it’s more of a skin scent.
Versatility:
This is one of Amber Oud Carbon Edition’s biggest strengths. The clean, green, citrusy profile is perfect for spring and summer, but it’s also great year-round indoors or in an office setting. It’s an ideal “grab and go” fragrance—works at the gym, in the boardroom, for a date, or just running errands. While it leans masculine, there’s nothing stopping anyone from wearing it; it’s a true people-pleaser.
Compliment Factor:
Let’s just say I’ve gotten more “You smell really good!” with this one than with a lot of my more expensive bottles. It’s inviting, professional, and fresh.
Value & Final Thoughts: Should You Buy It?
In a world of expensive niche fragrances, there’s something satisfying about finding a scent that delivers the high-end experience without the high-end price. Al Haramain Amber Oud Carbon Edition does exactly that. It’s not the most unique scent (because it’s modeled after a classic), but it’s very good at what it sets out to do.
Pros:
-
Very close to Creed Green Irish Tweed, at a fraction of the price
-
Fresh, versatile, easy to wear in any setting
-
Stronger, longer-lasting than most other “inspired by” alternatives
-
Professional, elegant presentation
Cons:
-
Not groundbreaking or wildly unique
-
The name is confusing (no amber or oud!)
-
If you already own GIT, you might not need this—but at this price, why not?
For anyone looking to expand their collection, save money, or simply enjoy that classic fresh “gentleman” scent, Amber Oud Carbon Edition is a fantastic blind buy. Just don’t be surprised if you reach for it more than some of your pricier bottles!
